ECAI Topic Selection
SkillProductivityUse before writing to decide whether a project belongs at ECAI versus IJCAI, AAAI, AAMAS, KR, or a pure-ML venue, and whether it should go to the ECAI main track or the co-located PAIS applications track, using contribution shape, the model-swap test, the European/general-AI fit, and the calendar (including the joint IJCAI-ECAI 2026 cycle).
Use ECAI Topic Selection in Claude, ChatGPT or Ahel Desktop
Free. Sign in, add ECAI Topic Selection and connect your AI. About a minute.
Also: Claude Code · Cursor · Codex
Then ask your AI: use the ECAI Topic Selection skill
Details
Instructions available. Your AI can read the instructions. Execution depends on the setup they require.
Account requirements not reviewed. Check the skill instructions before use; ahel provides instructions and does not run this skill.
No other account needed.
Add ahel to your AI once: Claude, ChatGPT, Cursor, Claude Code or Codex. Then ask it to use this.
What this skill tells your AI
The instructions your AI receives, as published by brycewang-stanford/awesome-journal-skills in ECAI-Skills/skills/ecai-topic-selection/SKILL.md and read by ahel’s review.
Routing is the highest-leverage decision, made before writing. ECAI is EurAI's general-AI flagship — broad by design, spanning symbolic reasoning, KR, planning, search, multi-agent systems, ML, and applications. That breadth is a feature and a trap: many projects could go to ECAI, so the real question is whether ECAI is the best-matched home for your contribution and calendar, and whether it belongs in the main track or the co-located PAIS applications track.
Is it ECAI-shaped?
ECAI wants a contribution a general AI audience recognizes as advancing how systems reason, plan, learn, or decide — with evidence proportional to the claim (a proof, or a fair comparison). Apply two tests:
- Model-swap test. If you replaced the underlying model/solver with another, would a lasting AI lesson remain? If yes → a genuine AI contribution (ECAI-shaped). If no → likely a pure-ML paper wearing an AI title (route to an ML venue).
- General-audience test. Could a reviewer from a different AI subfield see why the contribution matters? ECAI's broad pool rewards work that travels beyond one niche.
ECAI vs the sibling flagships
| If your contribution is... | Prefer | Because |
|---|---|---|
| Broad AI (symbolic + learning), European flagship, general audience | ECAI | EurAI's general-AI venue; breadth is the point |
| The same, but you want the international flagship / its calendar | IJCAI | In 2026 they are the same event (joint IJCAI-ECAI); in other years, different calendars/organizers |
| The same, but on the AAAI calendar / North-American flagship | AAAI | General AI too; different body, dates, template |
| Fundamentally about multi-agent interaction, mechanisms, negotiation | AAMAS | Dedicated MAS pool and reviewers |
| Pure knowledge representation / reasoning theory | KR | Specialist KR audience and depth |
| A benchmark-driven ML advance with no symbolic/decision lesson | NeurIPS/ICML | Pure-ML venues reward the leaderboard framing ECAI does not |
| A deployed, real-world AI application | ECAI → PAIS | PAIS is ECAI's prestigious-applications track |
Because these venues overlap, decide by best-matched reviewer pool + calendar + community pull, not by prestige alone. A paper matched to a specialist pool (AAMAS/KR) can fare better there than in ECAI's broad pool.
The 2026 twist: ECAI is joint with IJCAI
For this cycle, ECAI 2026 = IJCAI-ECAI 2026 (Bremen, 15-21 Aug 2026). So "ECAI vs IJCAI" is not
a choice in 2026 — it is one submission to the joint conference, following IJCAI's process,
template (ijcai.sty), 7+2 page budget, and open-access IJCAI proceedings. The standalone-ECAI
FAIA/ecai.cls/PAIS identity returns in a non-joint year. Confirm which regime your target edition
is in before routing (ecai-submission, ecai-camera-ready).
Main track vs PAIS
Route to PAIS (Prestigious Applications of Intelligent Systems, co-located with a standalone ECAI) when the contribution is a credible real-world deployment whose value is the application, not a new general mechanism:
- Main track: the contribution is a new technique, guarantee, or understanding that generalizes.
- PAIS: the contribution is a system that works in the real world — the lesson is the deployment, the constraints handled, the impact demonstrated.
PAIS has its own call and page budget (ECAI 2024: 7+1) and rewards impact and real conditions over
benchmark abstractions (ecai-experiments). Note PAIS is a standalone-ECAI fixture; verify
whether an applied track exists in a joint IJCAI-ECAI year (special tracks like AI4Tech, AI &
Robotics, AI & Health, AI & Social Good may serve that role — 待核实 per cycle).
Calendar-driven routing
- ECAI/IJCAI/AAAI run on different calendars (except the joint years). Route partly by which
deadline your work will actually be ready for — a rushed ECAI submission with a gap has no
revision round to save it (
ecai-review-process). - The two-deadline front (abstract, then paper) means you commit the title/abstract a week before the PDF; do not register an ECAI abstract you are not confident you can deliver.
Red flags that you are at the wrong venue
- The lesson evaporates under the model-swap test → ML venue.
- Only a specialist could care → AAMAS/KR.
- The value is a deployment, not a mechanism → PAIS.
- You are choosing ECAI over IJCAI in 2026 → they are the same event this year.
Output format
[Contribution shape] technique/guarantee / empirical understanding / multi-agent / KR theory / deployed system
[Model-swap test] AI lesson survives model swap? yes/no
[Venue] ECAI (main) / ECAI-PAIS / IJCAI / AAAI / AAMAS / KR / ML venue — with the deciding reason
[2026 regime] standalone ECAI or joint IJCAI-ECAI (same event as IJCAI this year)
[Calendar fit] ready for this deadline given no revision round? yes/no
Signals
- GitHub stars
- 1k
- Forks
- 155
- Last commit
- Sep 2026
Advanced
- Item type
- skill
- Key
ecai-topic-selection- Source
- github.com/brycewang-stanford/awesome-journal-skills
github.com/brycewang-stanford/awesome-journal-skills
Related picks
Skill · yusufkaraaslan
The pick for PDFpdf-co-automation
Skill · composio-community
The pick for PDFacademic-paper-composer
Skill · brycewang-stanford
The pick for Academic03-academic-writing
Skill · 24kchengye
The pick for Academicsocial
Skill · coreyhaines31
More in Productivitygws-calendar
Skill · googleworkspace
More in Productivity